Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Why Jews Dislike Palin

Here we go again. Every few years, some big media-saturated event lights up the internet with right-wing anti-Semitism, and the always-fragile level of tolerance the right grants Jewish people due to Israel and Jewish-American wealth and success begins to fade. Because no matter how much money Jews make, at the end of the day they still refuse to completely assimilate (read: vote Republican)

It's always strange to see the disparity between the right's support of the right wing of Israeli politics and their hatred and contempt for actual Jewish people. Evangelist Billy Graham is a right-wing Zionist, but he counseled Nixon about Hollywood Jews who subvert morality and promote liberalism. The Catholic League's Bill Donahue supports the Israeli right, and he also thinks "Hollywood is controlled by secular Jews who only care about anal sex." Ann Coulter can fellate the Likud party all she wants, but she revealed her true feelings about Jews to Danny Deutche last year, saying they need to be "perfected" like her. (I guess that means become crazy bigots with horse-faces.) It's easy to see why she and her buddies are mad at us. The old saying that Jews earn like Episcopalians but vote like Puerto Ricans is true and must be baffling to anyone who wonders why someone wouldn't vote with her pocketbook. Usually these Jew-baiting events involve Mel Gibson, but this time it comes from a surprising source: John McCain's camp.

McCain has made a Herculean effort to court Jewish voters. Whereas most Republicans in the past have written off Jews because they vote mostly Democratic, McCain has directly appealed to them. And some of his supporters have tried to capitalize on the anti-Muslim sentiments of some (especially older) Jewish people with aggressive, false propaganda about how Senator Barack Obama is secretly a militant Muslim.

That's why the turnaround is so shocking. Here's what happened: First, McCain chose Sarah Palin as his running mate. She is a nut-job who believes dinosaurs and humans once coexisted. She can't be bothered to read newspapers. She is against gay rights. She is against reproductive choice. We get it. Loves guns, hates gays. Really into hunting, but not so much into reading, learning, or science. So we (Jews) don't like her, naturally. That's the second stage of the turnaround. We reject this weirdo and make fun of her mercilessly in our fancy, city-folk jobs as reporters and Daily Show writers. That is all really predictable. If McCain thought Jews would warm up to a crazy Alaskan governor who hangs out with Jews For Jesus leaders, he must be as insane as she is.

But now the internet is awash with racists claiming Jews hate Palin because she is a Christian, and that this is further proof that Jews are anti-Christian bigots. Some are saying Jews are repeating the racism that was dealt to them by Christians in the past. This Jew-baiting claim is even making its way (in a nicer tone, of course) to mainstream sites like Beliefnet. Let's get three things clear:

1. Christianity is not a race, so it's impossible to be racist against Christians. Christianity is a CHOICE, like Scientology or Reform Judaism. Because we live in a civilized society, we should be civil towards each other and refrain from ridiculing someone's religion for no reason, but criticizing a religion is not racism. Anti-Semitism is racism because it is hatred against someone because of her ethnicity. Hating someone because her last name is Cohen is racism. However, criticizing Conservative Judaism is not racist because that's a religion. Therefore, criticizing Christianity is not racism.

2. Uh, we don't hate Christians. Most of us don't, anyway. According to Ha'aretz, Jewish voters favor Obama, and he is a Christian. Jews voted overwhelmingly for Bill Clinton and John Kerry, and they are both Christians. I'm pretty sure most Jews think Oskar Schindler was a good guy, and he was a Christian. We dislike Palin because she is crazy!!

3. If you want to strike a chord with Jewish voters, support legislation we can get behind. Most Jews want gay-straight equality, reproductive rights, socialized health care, and support for education and the arts. And a balanced approach to the Israeli-Palistinian conflict that respects the humanity of both peoples will make Israel more secure than just giving its right wing unchecked support.

Well, I hope that clears things up for you anti-Semites. I've got to get back to the cabal now. We've got some world-domination plans to draw up.

4 comments:

Frank Partisan said...

Thank you for visiting my blog. I hope you return.

Neither candidate had much to say at the debate on the Middle East, that was groundbreaking.

Sarah Palin is the most vacant politician at the level she was raised to, that I've ever known in my life. I dislike most about her, is her snarkiness. If you are stupid, atleast be humble.

JDHURF said...

You are exactly right when you point out that many, if not all, of the major right wing Christian commentators and leaders of advocacy groups support, upon first approximations paradoxically, the Israeli right – the Likud party, settlers in the OT who even now continue to expand and so on – while at the same time pumping anti-Semitism into the national discourse.

There is, of course, no paradox, the extremist Christian conception of the soon-to-be-coming apocalypse coupled with the ideology of archaic Christian anti-Semitism – charges of deicide and the like – informs and motivates such seeming paradoxes: they support the Israeli right because they are of the belief that this will help to initiate the glorious apocalypse that they pray day and night for; an apocalypse that will, among other things, result in the mass damnation of Jewish people for not accepting the absurdity of Christ.

You are further correct to point out that denunciation of specific dogmas inherent to a religion or denunciation of the religion in general does not and cannot constitute any form of racism or bigotry (assuming the denunciations are within the realm of reason). Therefore, when Jewish commentators denounce Palin’s beliefs and positions – which are informed by a very base and reactionary form of Christianity – they, by definition, cannot be engaging in anything remotely related to racism or bigotry.
Even further, when a Jewish commentator denounces, say, Palin’s laughable belief that dinosaurs and human beings once lived side by side, they are not even criticizing Christianity as such, but rather, a specific dogma within a specific form of Christianity.

I have many Christian friends and my family is predominately Christian, yet they too denounce Palin in just the same way. Are we now to be told that liberal and progressive Christians – Christians who are not raving maniacs – are themselves anti-Christian racists and bigots? Clearly such a conclusion is absurd and serves to only further refute such hysterics.

Great post, mazel tov!

tokugawa smile said...

Renegade Eye,

Yeah, I liked what I read, and I can't wait to see Religulous this Saturday night. And yes, she IS snarky.

JDHURF,

Thanks!! And good point about how given the crazies' line of reasoning, we would have to say progressive Christians are anti-Christian bigots as well.

Thank you both for stopping by!!

Ronbot Van Helsing said...

Why does it not surprise me that SCIENTOLOGIST Greta Van Susteren has been given the task of softball-interviewing SCIENTOLOGY-CONNECTED Sarah Palin on the "Fair and Balanced" SCIENTOLOGY-SYMPATHETIC Fox News Network?

Sarah Palin is connected to Scientology. Here's how:

She has been, and still continues to be, deeply involved with the ultra-right-wing "Dominionist" church movement. READ THIS:

http://markcrispinmiller.blogspot.com/2008/09/sarah-palin-and-cnp.html

The main nexus for the Dominionists is the "Committee on National Policy", which strangely includes non-Christian organizations such as, yes, The Church of Scientology.

The leading "Dominionist" church is MorningStar ministries, which
despite being a Christian church, leans heavily on "supernatural" themes and blatantly uses the Scientology Cross in their logo:

http://www.morningstarministries.org/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_cross